Planning an HRIS upgrade, migration, or optimization? Explore the top 20 real-world challenges reported by Workday, UKG, Oracle/PeopleSoft, and ADP customers across 2025 and 2026—and how to protect your organization.
Enterprise and mid-market HR leaders invested heavily in cloud HR transformations over the past several years, expecting seamless automation, AI-assisted workflows, and instant workforce analytics. Yet across user communities, peer reviews, and post-implementation retrospectives in 2025 and 2026, a far more nuanced reality emerged.
While Workday, UKG, Oracle (Cloud HCM & PeopleSoft), and ADP remain the dominant pillars of human capital management, customers across all four ecosystems ran into compounding operational friction—ranging from forced UI overhauls and legacy sunset migrations to AI "token-burn" pricing and high-profile platform outages.
At BTGSI, we help organizations navigate complex HRIS selections, migrations, and post-go-live optimizations. Below is our updated breakdown of the top 20 customer-reported HRIS issues spanning 2025 and 2026—and what HR and IT leaders must watch out for when evaluating or managing these platforms.
1. Cross-Platform & Systemic Issues (All 4 Vendors)
Five foundational pain points continued to frustrate HRIS administrators throughout 2025 and 2026, regardless of which platform powered their organization.
1. Post-Go-Live Support Degradation & AI-First Ticket Deflection
Across all four vendors—most acutely in UKG and ADP—customers reported a steep drop in support responsiveness after implementation. Aggressive shifts toward AI chatbots and tiered ticket routing left HRIS admins struggling to reach knowledgeable human specialists during urgent payroll or tax-filing emergencies.
2. Severe Ticket Backlogs & Constant Case Re-Explanation
Complex escalations frequently dragged on for weeks or months. High turnover among account managers and support reps forced administrators to repeatedly re-explain intricate configurations across multiple handoffs.
3. Opaque AI Pricing, "Token Burn" & Escalating TCO
In 2025, buyers flagged "module creep" behind higher subscription tiers. By 2026, customers increasingly pushed back against consumption-based AI agent models and add-on licensing—noting that out-of-the-box AI agents often delivered limited value unless organizations invested heavily in custom configuration or paid steep usage costs.
4. Custom Reporting Learning Curves & Manual Rework
Extracting actionable insights remained painful. Workday users cited heavy reliance on specialized consultants to build calculated fields and custom reports, while ADP Workforce Now operators continued reporting the need to manually strip merged header rows and rebuild spreadsheet columns before exports could be used by Finance.
5. Forced UI Redesigns That Add Friction Instead of Speed
Both 2025 and 2026 saw major interface pushes across vendors—including Workday's 2026R2 UI changes, Oracle's mandatory Redwood UI migration, and UKG Pro's upcoming mandatory UI redesign. Rather than celebrating these updates, everyday users and admins widely complained of bloated spacing, less data visible on screen, broken muscle memory, and more clicks required for routine tasks.
2. Workday-Specific Customer Issues
Workday continues to lead in enterprise cloud architecture, yet 2025–2026 highlighted notable operational, UI, and governance challenges:
6. High-Impact Maintenance Outages & Backup Test Disruptions (2026)
In November 2026, a Workday disaster-recovery backup test left production data inconsistent for affected customers, forcing Workday to take systems into emergency maintenance over a Friday and Saturday—locking workers out of timekeeping, pay visibility, and benefits enrollment.
7. 2026R2 UI & Profile Privacy Complaints
Administrators and employees pushed back hard against Workday's 2026R2 interface updates. Users reported oversized text and spacing that truncated search dropdowns on split screens, harder-to-find Related Actions, and profile layout changes that exposed sensitive net-pay details during screen-shares or admin proxying.
8. Third-Party CRM & OAuth Supply-Chain Exposures (2025)
While Workday's core HCM tenants remained unbreached, two high-profile third-party incidents in August 2025 (the ShinyHunters vishing attack and the Salesloft Drift OAuth token compromise) exposed business contact records and support case histories via connected CRM environments, forcing admins to audit OAuth scopes and tighten vendor governance.
9. Overwhelming Security Model & Consultant Dependency
Workday's role-based and domain security architecture remains exceptionally granular, but modifying business processes (BPs), building integrations, or auditing permissions without breaking downstream workflows still requires niche, expensive internal or external expertise.
3. UKG (Pro, Workforce Management & Ready) Issues
UKG remains a powerhouse for hourly and frontline workforces, though mandatory migrations and configuration bottlenecks dominated customer feedback in 2025–2026:
10. Painful Legacy Migrations from Workforce Central to UKG Pro WFM (2026)
With UKG sunsetting legacy Workforce Central (WFC), thousands of healthcare, manufacturing, and retail organizations faced complex migrations in 2026. Customers discovered that legacy WFC customizations and integrations cannot simply be "lifted and shifted," requiring full pay-rule redesigns and extensive parallel payroll testing to avoid post-go-live payroll instability.
11. Disconnected UX & Mandatory UI Transition Pressure
Customers continued reporting friction between core HR/Payroll (UKG Pro) and Workforce Management (legacy Kronos Dimensions), compounded in late 2026 by preparation for UKG Pro's new user interface—which becomes mandatory in February 2027 and disrupts established admin muscle memory in scheduling and paycode management.
12. Recurring Payroll Exceptions & "UKG Hero" Burnout
Many organizations reported relying on manual spreadsheet audits, off-cycle payroll runs, and one or two overworked internal "UKG heroes" because complex union, shift-differential, and accrual rules were never fully aligned with real-world labor policies.
13. Mobile App Friction & Benefit Carrier Feed Delays
Deskless employees continued citing sluggish mobile load times and geofencing glitches, while HR admins reported slow troubleshooting when EDI/API benefit feeds failed to transmit to third-party carriers during open enrollment or life events.
4. Oracle (Cloud HCM & PeopleSoft) Issues
Oracle customers spent 2025 and 2026 navigating polarizing cloud UI transitions on one side and infrastructure shifts on the other:
14. Frustrating Oracle Cloud HCM Migrations to Redwood UI (2025–2026)
Organizations transitioning from Oracle's Responsive UI to the mandatory Redwood UI reported sluggish page loads, browser caching bugs, truncated columns on compensation admin pages, and transactions failing or requiring custom workarounds where classic pages previously worked smoothly.
15. Lengthy, High-Risk Cloud HCM Implementations
Organizations migrating to Oracle Cloud HCM continued reporting multi-month to multi-year deployments requiring heavy internal IT governance, where early configuration missteps frequently cascaded into downstream general ledger and payroll audit errors.
16. PeopleSoft PUM Containerization & Technical Maintenance Shifts (2026)
While Oracle extended PeopleSoft 9.2 Premier Support through at least 2037 and introduced PeopleTools 8.63 AI capabilities in 2026, day-to-day maintenance grew more complex. Oracle began deprecating VirtualBox-based PeopleSoft Update Manager (PUM) deployments in favor of Podman containers—forcing legacy PeopleSoft admins to re-engineer patch workflows on top of decades of custom PeopleCode debt.
17. Third-Party Support Wind-Downs & PeopleTools Lock-In
PeopleSoft customers evaluating or using third-party maintenance faced heightened strategic pressure in 2026—especially following Rimini Street's settlement requiring it to wind down PeopleSoft support by July 2028—leaving organizations stuck between paying Oracle's 22% annual maintenance fees or freezing their certified PeopleTools/database stack.
5. ADP (Workforce Now & Vantage) Issues
ADP remains trusted for core payroll tax compliance, yet mid-market and enterprise users ran into platform stability and rigidity walls across 2025 and 2026:
18. Multi-Day Workforce Now Performance Disruptions (October 2026)
In late October 2026, ADP Workforce Now suffered widespread latency, blank screens, page failures, and timecard disruptions stretching across multiple business days. Practitioners also voiced frustration that real-time status updates were gated behind practitioner-only logins on The Bridge, leaving wider HR and operations teams in the dark.
19. Inflexible Workflows & Accrual Rule Limitations
HR teams with non-standard policies continued reporting platform rigidity—such as Time Off modules struggling to enforce hard caps on employees transitioning between tenure accrual tiers, leading to accidental PTO overages.
20. Fragmented Product Roadmaps & Complex Multi-Job / Union Escalation Delays
Because ADP maintains multiple overlapping platforms (RUN, Workforce Now, Vantage, Lyric, TotalSource), customers reported uneven feature rollouts, legacy utility overlap, and slow escalation resolution when handling dual union/non-union employee roles or multi-state tax amendment filings ahead of statutory deadlines.
Quick Comparison: Where Each Vendor Struggled Most (2025–2026)
| Vendor | Primary Customer Pain Point | Secondary Operational Bottleneck |
|---|---|---|
| Workday | High TCO, AI pricing/consultant reliance & 2026R2 UI friction | Backup test outages (Nov 2026) & third-party OAuth security hygiene |
| UKG | Complex WFC-to-UKG Pro WFM migrations & support delays | Mandatory UI transition (Feb 2027) & manual payroll exception rework |
| Oracle / PSFT | Sluggish Redwood UI transitions & long Cloud HCM deployments | PeopleSoft Podman container shifts & third-party support disruptions |
| ADP | Post-go-live support delays & Oct 2026 WFN performance outages | Rigid accrual/workflow rules & manual cleanup for report exports |
How to Protect Your Organization Heading Into 2027
The lessons of 2025 and 2026 make one thing clear: vendor roadmaps and forced UI/architecture migrations are moving faster than many internal HRIS teams can absorb. The organizations seeing the highest ROI aren't necessarily the ones with the biggest software budgets—they are the ones that stress-test edge cases before migrating, negotiate post-go-live SLA and pricing protections into their contracts, and maintain dedicated internal or partner HRIS governance.
Need an unbiased partner for your HRIS roadmap? Whether you are navigating a UKG WFM or Oracle Redwood transition, preparing an RFP, or auditing your current system's Total Cost of Ownership, BTGSI helps HR and IT leaders turn complex enterprise software into a competitive advantage. Contact our HRIS advisory team today to schedule a diagnostic consultation.



